The Sign of the Four is a novel by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, featuring his famous detective Sherlock Holmes. Published in 1890, it is the second book in the Sherlock Holmes series and revolves around a complex plot of treasure and murder, with themes of love, betrayal, and justice intertwined. The story unfolds through the eyes of Dr. John Watson, Holmes’ trusted friend and chronicler, providing a detailed account of their investigative journey.

Comprehensive Plot Summary

Sherlock Holmes reclined in his armchair, his eyes fixed on the ceiling, while Dr. John Watson observed his friend with growing concern. The detective’s habit of using a seven-percent solution of cocaine had become a daily ritual, one that Watson, with his medical background, could no longer ignore. Their ordinary day is disrupted by the arrival of Miss Mary Morstan, a young woman with a delicate beauty and an aura of quiet desperation. Miss Morstan seeks Holmes’ help in unraveling the mystery of her missing father and the pearls she has been receiving annually.

Miss Morstan’s father, Captain Arthur Morstan, vanished ten years ago under mysterious circumstances. Since then, she has received a lustrous pearl each year on the same date, without any note or explanation. Recently, she received a letter asking her to meet at a designated place and time, promising to shed light on her father’s disappearance. Intrigued, Holmes agrees to take the case, and Watson accompanies them to the rendezvous.

At the meeting point, they are escorted by a coachman to the residence of Thaddeus Sholto. Thaddeus, a nervous and peculiar man, reveals that his father, Major Sholto, was Captain Morstan’s close friend and confidant. He recounts the night of Morstan’s disappearance, explaining that Morstan had come to Sholto’s home to discuss a treasure they had acquired in India. During a heated argument, Morstan suffered a fatal heart attack. Fearful of being accused of murder, Major Sholto concealed Morstan’s body and kept the treasure a secret.

Thaddeus takes Holmes, Watson, and Miss Morstan to Pondicherry Lodge, the Sholto family estate, where the treasure is supposedly hidden. Upon arrival, they find Bartholomew Sholto, Thaddeus’ twin brother, dead in his locked room. A note bearing the phrase “The Sign of the Four” is found near his body, and the treasure chest is missing. Holmes deduces that the killer is Jonathan Small, an ex-convict seeking to reclaim the treasure he believes is his by right.

Holmes’ investigation leads him to discover that Small, along with three Indian convicts, conspired to steal the treasure during the Indian Rebellion of 1857. Small, having lost a leg to a crocodile, had formed an alliance with a native named Tonga. Using his extraordinary deductive skills, Holmes tracks Small and Tonga to a boat chase on the Thames River. In a thrilling pursuit, Holmes and Watson capture Small, but Tonga is killed in the process.

Under interrogation, Small confesses that he and the other convicts had indeed stolen the treasure. However, they were betrayed by a corrupt British officer who had promised them a share but instead imprisoned them. Small managed to keep part of the treasure hidden, planning to retrieve it upon his escape. The pearls Miss Morstan received were Small’s attempt to make partial amends for the wrongs done to her father.

With Small in custody, Holmes, Watson, and Miss Morstan return to Pondicherry Lodge, where they finally open the treasure chest. To their astonishment, it is empty, save for a few worthless trinkets. The true treasure, it seems, had been spirited away long before. Despite this disappointment, the bond formed between Watson and Miss Morstan grows stronger. In the midst of their shared adventure and the emotional turmoil, Watson realizes his deep affection for her. He proposes, and she accepts, marking a bright spot in an otherwise grim series of events.

The capture of Jonathan Small and the resolution of the case bring some closure to Miss Morstan regarding her father’s fate. Holmes, satisfied with the intellectual challenge the case provided, retreats back to his familiar quarters at Baker Street. Watson, now engaged to Miss Morstan, reflects on the adventure that brought them together. The case, though fraught with danger and deception, ultimately leads to a new chapter in his life, filled with hope and companionship.

Main Characters

  • Sherlock Holmes: The brilliant and eccentric detective whose keen powers of observation and deduction unravel the complex mystery.
  • Dr. John Watson: Holmes’ loyal friend and biographer, whose narrative provides a personal and humane perspective to the story.
  • Miss Mary Morstan: The client whose quest to uncover her father’s fate and the mystery of the pearls drives the plot forward.
  • Thaddeus Sholto: The nervous and somewhat peculiar son of Major Sholto, who reveals the truth about Captain Morstan’s death.
  • Jonathan Small: The antagonist, whose pursuit of the hidden treasure leads to murder and deception.

Themes and Motifs

  • Justice and Retribution: The story explores the concept of justice, both legal and moral, as characters seek to rectify past wrongs and claim what they believe is rightfully theirs.
  • Colonialism and Greed: The treasure’s origins in colonial India and the characters’ relentless pursuit of wealth highlight the themes of greed and the moral consequences of colonial exploitation.
  • Friendship and Loyalty: Holmes and Watson’s friendship is a central theme, showcasing their mutual respect and loyalty amidst the challenges they face.
  • Love and Sacrifice: Watson’s love for Miss Morstan and his willingness to stand by her, even in danger, adds an emotional depth to the narrative.

Writing Style and Tone

Arthur Conan Doyle’s writing style in The Sign of the Four is characterized by its clear, concise prose and the use of vivid descriptions to create a strong sense of atmosphere. The tone of the novel is one of suspense and intrigue, with moments of dramatic tension interspersed with instances of dry humor, particularly in the interactions between Holmes and Watson.

Doyle’s skillful use of first-person narration through Watson’s perspective allows readers to experience the mystery unfold alongside the characters, making the story engaging and immersive. The language is formal yet accessible, reflecting the Victorian era’s literary standards while remaining appealing to modern readers.

Opinions are my own and not the views of my employer (if any)

When I am not working/watching movies/reading books/traveling, you can reach me via my Twitter/LinkedIn or you can contact me here

Categories: Book Summary