“The Murders in the Rue Morgue,” written by Edgar Allan Poe, is a pioneering work in the detective fiction genre. The story is set in Paris and follows the brilliant yet eccentric C. Auguste Dupin, who uses his analytical prowess to solve a baffling and brutal double murder. The narrative delves into themes of observation, logic, and the nature of human intellect, setting the tone for future detective stories.

Comprehensive Plot Summary

In the heart of Paris during the spring of 18—, the narrator becomes acquainted with Monsieur C. Auguste Dupin, a young gentleman of noble lineage but reduced means. Dupin, despite his fallen fortunes, possesses a keen intellect and a passion for analysis. They bond over their shared love of books and soon decide to live together in a dilapidated mansion in the Faubourg Saint-Germain. Here, they indulge in their peculiar routines, shunning society and reveling in intellectual pursuits, particularly during their nocturnal excursions through the city.

One night, their tranquil existence is disrupted by an article in the Gazette des Tribunaux, detailing a gruesome double murder in the Rue Morgue. Madame L’Espanaye and her daughter, Mademoiselle Camille, have been found dead under shocking circumstances. The older woman’s body is discovered in the courtyard, her throat savagely cut, while the daughter’s corpse is found wedged in the chimney, bearing signs of strangulation. The room where the murders occurred is in chaos, with broken furniture, blood-stained razors, and scattered coins.

The Parisian police, renowned for their investigative prowess, are baffled. Witnesses report hearing two voices during the crime—a deep, gruff voice speaking French, and a shrill, foreign-sounding one. Despite thorough questioning and investigation, no clear suspects emerge, and the case remains a mystery. The police arrest Adolphe Le Bon, a man with no apparent motive, simply because he had delivered gold to the L’Espanaye residence a few days before the murders.

Intrigued and driven by a sense of justice, Dupin decides to investigate. He has a personal connection to Le Bon, who once rendered him a service. Dupin and the narrator visit the crime scene, meticulously examining the details. Dupin’s keen observations and analytical mind quickly lead him to question the police’s conclusions, particularly regarding the mode of entry and exit. The locked doors and windows suggest an impossible crime, yet Dupin discovers a hidden spring mechanism in one of the windows, indicating that it could have been opened from the outside.

Dupin carefully retraces the sequence of events, piecing together clues that the police overlooked. His deductions reveal an astonishing conclusion: the murders were committed by an orangutan. This revelation stems from a series of logical inferences, starting with the peculiar nature of the second voice and culminating in the discovery of a tuft of non-human hair at the scene. The orangutan, Dupin deduces, had escaped from a Maltese sailor and, in a fit of panic and confusion, killed the two women.

Dupin places an advertisement in a local newspaper, claiming the capture of the animal and inviting its owner to retrieve it. The sailor, identified through the distinctive knot used in his hair ribbon, arrives at Dupin’s residence. Dupin and the narrator detain him, and he recounts the tragic chain of events: the orangutan, imitating the sailor’s shaving routine with a razor, had accidentally caused the deaths in a fit of panic when the women resisted.

With the sailor’s testimony, Dupin clears Le Bon of all charges. The Prefect of Police, though reluctant, acknowledges Dupin’s superior investigative skills. The narrative concludes with a reflection on the power of analytical reasoning, as Dupin’s unique talents restore order to the chaos of the Rue Morgue murders.

Through this harrowing investigation, Dupin’s intellect shines, unraveling the mystery with precision and uncovering the truth hidden beneath layers of confusion and fear. The murders in the Rue Morgue are a testament to his unparalleled analytical abilities, setting a precedent for future investigations and establishing Dupin as a master of deduction.

Residing in Paris during the spring and part of the summer of 18—, the narrator meets Monsieur C. Auguste Dupin. Dupin is of an illustrious family but has been reduced to poverty. Despite his financial hardships, Dupin is a man of intellect and analytical prowess. The two become friends and decide to live together in a timeworn mansion in the Faubourg Saint-Germain. Their lives are a blend of seclusion and nocturnal adventures, where they explore the city under the cover of night.

One evening, their peace is shattered by a horrific news report. The Gazette des Tribunaux describes the brutal murders of Madame L’Espanaye and her daughter, Mademoiselle Camille, in the Rue Morgue. The crime scene is grotesque: Madame L’Espanaye is found decapitated in the courtyard, and Mademoiselle Camille is discovered with her body grotesquely stuffed up a chimney. The room is in shambles, with blood everywhere, broken furniture, and valuables scattered about.

The Parisian police, known for their investigative skills, are at a loss. Witnesses report hearing two voices: one gruff and French, the other shrill and foreign. Despite extensive investigations and numerous interviews, the police can find no concrete leads. Adolphe Le Bon, who had recently delivered gold to the L’Espanaye household, is arrested, but there is no substantial evidence against him.

Dupin, intrigued and feeling a sense of duty, decides to investigate. He remembers a favor Le Bon had done for him and feels compelled to help. Dupin and the narrator visit the crime scene, and Dupin’s acute analytical skills soon reveal discrepancies in the police’s conclusions. Dupin notices a hidden spring mechanism in one of the windows, suggesting that the room could have been accessed from the outside.

As Dupin reconstructs the events of the night, he forms a shocking hypothesis: an orangutan committed the murders. This conclusion comes from various observations, including the strange second voice and the discovery of unusual hair at the scene. Dupin theorizes that the orangutan, owned by a Maltese sailor, had escaped and, in a panic, killed the two women.

Dupin places an advertisement in a local newspaper, claiming to have captured the orangutan and inviting its owner to come forward. The sailor, identified by the distinctive knot in his hair ribbon, responds to the ad and visits Dupin. Dupin and the narrator detain the sailor, who recounts the events. The orangutan, attempting to imitate the sailor’s shaving routine, accidentally killed the women when they resisted its frightening presence.

The sailor’s testimony clears Le Bon, and Dupin’s astute deductions impress even the reluctant Prefect of Police. Dupin’s analytical brilliance restores order to the chaos surrounding the Rue Morgue murders, demonstrating the power of keen observation and deductive reasoning. The mystery is solved, and Dupin’s reputation as a master detective is cemented.

Main Characters

  • C. Auguste Dupin: A reclusive and intellectually gifted man who uses his extraordinary analytical abilities to solve complex mysteries. His keen powers of observation and deduction are central to the story.
  • The Narrator: A close friend of Dupin who admires his friend’s talents and provides a detailed account of the investigation. His perspective helps to humanize Dupin and offer insights into their unique relationship.
  • Madame L’Espanaye: An elderly woman found brutally murdered in her home. Her tragic end sets the stage for Dupin’s investigation.
  • Mademoiselle Camille L’Espanaye: The daughter of Madame L’Espanaye, also murdered in a horrifying manner. Her body is discovered in the chimney, indicating the brutality of the crime.
  • Adolphe Le Bon: An innocent man wrongfully imprisoned for the murders. His plight motivates Dupin to uncover the true perpetrator.
  • The Maltese Sailor: The owner of the orangutan, whose story and connection to the animal provide the crucial link to solving the mystery.
  • The Orangutan: The actual perpetrator of the murders, whose actions, though unintentional, result in a gruesome tragedy.

Themes and Motifs

  • Analytical Reasoning: The story celebrates the power of the human intellect and analytical reasoning, as demonstrated by Dupin’s methodical approach to solving the mystery.
  • The Nature of Observation: Poe emphasizes the importance of keen observation and the ability to notice details that others might overlook, a skill that Dupin excels at.
  • Human vs. Animal Nature: The narrative explores the thin line between human and animal behavior, highlighting the unpredictability and potential for violence inherent in both.
  • Isolation and Connection: Dupin and the narrator’s secluded lifestyle contrasts with the chaotic public interest in the murders, reflecting themes of isolation and the desire for human connection.

Writing Style and Tone

Edgar Allan Poe’s writing in “The Murders in the Rue Morgue” is characterized by its meticulous attention to detail and logical structure. The tone is both analytical and gothic, creating a sense of eerie suspense and intellectual curiosity. Poe’s narrative technique blends a methodical dissection of facts with rich, atmospheric descriptions, immersing the reader in the grim and mysterious world of 19th-century Paris.

Poe employs a first-person perspective through the narrator, allowing for a personal and contemplative recounting of events. The language is precise and, at times, ornate, reflecting the narrator’s admiration for Dupin’s intellect and the complexity of the mystery. The story’s structure, with its gradual revelation of clues and logical deductions, exemplifies Poe’s mastery of the detective fiction genre, laying the groundwork for future literary sleuths.

Opinions are my own and not the views of my employer (if any)

When I am not working/watching movies/reading books/traveling, you can reach me via my Twitter/LinkedIn or you can contact me here

Categories: Book Summary