“An American Tragedy,” written by Theodore Dreiser and published in 1925, is a landmark in American literature. The novel is a profound exploration of the American Dream’s dark side, where ambition, desire, and moral ambiguity intertwine to create a compelling narrative. Set in the early 20th century, the story delves into the life of Clyde Griffiths, a young man whose pursuit of wealth and status leads him down a tragic path. Dreiser’s work is a reflection on the societal pressures and personal flaws that shape the human condition, making it a timeless and thought-provoking read.

Comprehensive Plot Summary

“An American Tragedy” begins with Clyde Griffiths, the son of poor, devoutly religious parents who run a street mission. From an early age, Clyde is discontent with his family’s poverty and their rigid moral code. He dreams of a more glamorous life, free from the confines of his current existence. This desire intensifies when he takes a job as a bellboy at the luxurious Green-Davidson Hotel. The hotel exposes him to a world of wealth, indulgence, and sophistication that he has never known. Here, Clyde begins to partake in activities that are far removed from his strict upbringing, such as drinking, partying, and engaging in romantic flings.

One fateful night, Clyde and his friends borrow a car for a joyride. The evening takes a tragic turn when they hit and kill a young girl while speeding through the streets. Terrified, Clyde flees the scene, leaving his old life behind. He moves to Chicago, where he struggles with low-paying jobs and a sense of aimlessness. His fortunes change when he reconnects with his wealthy uncle, Samuel Griffiths, who offers him a position at his collar factory in Lycurgus, New York.

Clyde eagerly accepts the job, seeing it as an opportunity to escape his past and climb the social ladder. In Lycurgus, he is initially assigned to a menial position in the factory. However, his charm and determination soon catch the attention of his superiors, and he is promoted to a slightly better role. Despite this progress, Clyde remains dissatisfied, yearning for the lifestyle of the wealthy elite he glimpses from afar.

Clyde’s life becomes more complicated when he becomes romantically involved with Roberta Alden, a beautiful but poor factory worker. Their relationship is passionate but clandestine, as the factory has strict rules against fraternization between supervisors and workers. Clyde is careful to keep their affair a secret, fearing it could jeopardize his budding career.

Meanwhile, Clyde becomes infatuated with Sondra Finchley, a wealthy socialite who embodies everything he desires. Sondra is beautiful, charming, and moves in the circles of high society that Clyde longs to join. She represents the ultimate prize in his quest for upward mobility. To win her favor, Clyde starts distancing himself from Roberta, who grows increasingly anxious about their future.

Roberta soon discovers she is pregnant, throwing Clyde into a state of panic. Desperate to avoid scandal and protect his chances with Sondra, Clyde considers various ways to deal with the situation. He contemplates marriage but quickly discards the idea, fearing it would ruin his social aspirations. Roberta, feeling abandoned and desperate, pressures Clyde for a solution, which only heightens his sense of entrapment.

As Clyde’s desperation mounts, he devises a chilling plan. He suggests a trip to the remote Big Bittern Lake, intending to stage an accident that will free him from his obligations to Roberta. The plan is fraught with moral ambiguity and internal conflict, but Clyde’s fear of losing his chance with Sondra drives him forward. During the boat ride on the lake, Clyde hesitates, struggling with his conscience. In a moment of panic and confusion, he accidentally knocks Roberta into the water. Instead of rescuing her, Clyde lets her drown, unable to bring himself to save her.

Clyde’s actions are driven by fear and confusion, leading to his eventual arrest and trial for murder. The trial becomes a sensational event, reflecting the societal fascination with scandal and the fall of the seemingly privileged. Despite the defense’s efforts to portray the death as an accident, Clyde is convicted and sentenced to death.

As Clyde awaits execution, he reflects on his life and the choices that led him to this point. His final days are marked by a sense of inevitability and remorse, as he grapples with the realization that his ambitions and desires have brought him nothing but ruin.

Main Characters

  • Clyde Griffiths: The protagonist, whose journey from poverty to ambition leads to moral and legal downfall. His inner conflict and desire for a better life drive the narrative.
  • Roberta Alden: A factory worker who becomes romantically involved with Clyde and whose untimely death is central to the plot. Her innocence and vulnerability highlight the tragedy of Clyde’s actions.
  • Sondra Finchley: A wealthy socialite who represents the life Clyde desires. Her charm and status entice Clyde, exacerbating his moral dilemmas.
  • Samuel Griffiths: Clyde’s wealthy uncle, whose influence provides Clyde with the opportunity to improve his social standing but also exposes him to further temptations.
  • Gilbert Griffiths: Samuel’s son and Clyde’s cousin, who serves as a foil to Clyde. His established position and relationship with Sondra highlight Clyde’s outsider status.

Themes and Motifs

  • The American Dream: The novel critiques the idea that anyone can achieve success through hard work, showing how ambition can lead to moral compromise and tragedy.
  • Class and Social Mobility: Clyde’s struggle to rise above his humble origins illustrates the rigid class structures and the illusions of upward mobility.
  • Moral Ambiguity: The story explores the complexities of morality, particularly through Clyde’s actions and justifications, highlighting the gray areas of human behavior.
  • Justice and Injustice: The trial and its outcome raise questions about the fairness of the legal system and the societal influences on justice.
  • Fatalism: The sense of inevitability that pervades Clyde’s life underscores the deterministic nature of his downfall, suggesting that his fate was sealed by his choices and circumstances.

Writing Style and Tone

Theodore Dreiser’s writing style in “An American Tragedy” is characterized by its detailed realism and naturalistic approach. Dreiser meticulously depicts the social environments and psychological states of his characters, allowing readers to fully immerse themselves in the narrative. His prose is often dense and descriptive, providing a comprehensive view of the characters’ inner lives and the external forces shaping their actions. Dreiser’s use of multiple perspectives and in-depth character studies contributes to the novel’s rich and multifaceted portrayal of early 20th-century American society.

The tone of the novel is somber and reflective, capturing the tragic elements of Clyde’s story and the broader societal issues it addresses. Dreiser’s narrative voice is both empathetic and critical, offering a compassionate view of Clyde’s struggles while simultaneously condemning the societal values that contribute to his downfall. This duality creates a powerful and thought-provoking reading experience, encouraging readers to contemplate the complexities of ambition, morality, and the American Dream.

Opinions are my own and not the views of my employer (if any)

When I am not working/watching movies/reading books/traveling, you can reach me via my Twitter/LinkedIn or you can contact me here

Categories: Book Summary