“A Thief in the Night” by Ernest William Hornung is a collection of short stories centered around A. J. Raffles, a gentleman thief, and his companion, Bunny Manders. Published in 1905, it continues the adventures of the infamous Raffles, who is a master of disguise, a brilliant strategist, and a cricket enthusiast. Set in late Victorian London, these stories delve into the duo’s intricate heists, moral ambiguities, and the complex relationship between Raffles and Bunny.

Comprehensive Plot Summary

Out of the shadows of Victorian London emerges A. J. Raffles, a man of many talents and a master of disguise. Known to society as a celebrated cricketer, Raffles harbors a secret life as a gentleman thief, a duality he navigates with charm and cunning. His loyal companion, Bunny Manders, narrates their adventures, revealing the complexities of their relationship and the moral ambiguities that define their lives.

The adventure begins with Bunny reflecting on his early days with Raffles, recalling a significant betrayal that forever changed his life. Bunny had been engaged to a woman of high standing, a delicate arrangement frowned upon by her aristocratic family. His unworthiness, compounded by a desperate need to settle gambling debts, led him to Raffles, who, in his typical charismatic manner, devised a plan to rob Hector Carruthers, a wealthy politician.

Carruthers’ house, located in the opulent Palace Gardens, was a fortress of wealth and security. Bunny, familiar with the household from past visits, provided Raffles with critical information about the house’s layout, including the well-hidden safe. Despite Bunny’s initial reluctance and moral hesitation, Raffles’ persuasive charm and the thrill of the heist drew him into the plan.

One evening, after a celebratory dinner at the Café Royal, Raffles and Bunny set out for Carruthers’ house. Disguised and armed with tools of the trade, they approached the grand residence under the cover of darkness. The house, dimly lit with a few stray lights, seemed almost asleep, but Raffles’ keen eye detected signs of recent activity. The presence of a light in the stables suggested that not all the household was abed, adding an element of risk to their venture.

Raffles, ever the strategist, led Bunny through the garden, avoiding the gravel paths that might betray their presence. They reached the porch, and with a deft hand, Raffles unlocked the door and drew Bunny into the house. The hall clock chimed ominously, a reminder of the passage of time and the dangers that lay ahead. As Raffles worked on the study door, Bunny kept watch, his nerves frayed by the ticking clock and the possibility of discovery.

Their intrusion was not unnoticed. As Raffles manipulated the lock, Bunny heard the cautious opening of a door in the gallery above. A woman, dressed in a ball gown and holding a candle, descended the stairs. Bunny’s heart pounded as he recognized her—the woman he had once hoped to marry. She moved with purpose to a small table where she intended to post a letter. The ticking clock seemed to amplify the tension in the air.

Bunny’s suppressed emotions overcame him, and he groaned, drawing the woman’s attention. She peered into the shadows where Bunny and Raffles stood concealed. Raffles, sensing the imminent danger, signaled for a retreat. But as they prepared to escape, the sound of knocking and ringing at the front door shattered the silence. It was the son of the house returning, accompanied by officers of the law.

Raffles bolted through the window, engaging in a brief but fierce struggle with one of the officers before disappearing into the night. Bunny, caught in the hallway, was saved by the woman who hid him in a cupboard under the stairs. The house erupted in chaos as voices called out and feet pounded overhead. Bunny, trapped and tormented by his emotions, could only wait in silence.

Eventually, the commotion subsided, and the woman, her face etched with sorrow and resolve, urged Bunny to leave. As he made his way to the porch, he encountered Raffles, disguised as a concerned bystander. Together, they assisted in the futile search for the intruder, maintaining their cover. Bunny’s anger and sense of betrayal simmered beneath the surface, directed as much at himself as at Raffles.

The heist at Carruthers’ house marked a turning point for Bunny. His involvement with Raffles had cost him dearly, yet he remained bound to the enigmatic thief by loyalty and a sense of camaraderie. Raffles, ever the pragmatist, had already moved on to his next venture, planning a trip to Scotland to refine his dialects and expand his criminal repertoire.

Before departing, Raffles entrusted Bunny with a chest of silver, instructing him to deposit it at his bank. Bunny’s unease grew as he complied, especially after a daring robbery at the bank threatened to expose Raffles’ secrets. The news of the attempted heist sent Bunny into a state of panic, fearing the worst for Raffles and the incriminating contents of the chest.

Raffles’ return brought both relief and further complications. He revealed that he was the burglar who had nearly been caught at the bank, demonstrating his audacity and skill. Bunny’s admiration for Raffles clashed with his growing sense of disillusionment. The duo’s bond was tested as Bunny grappled with the moral implications of their actions and the personal sacrifices he had made.

Despite the turmoil, Bunny’s loyalty to Raffles remained unshaken. Their adventures continued, marked by ingenious heists and narrow escapes. The allure of Raffles’ world, with its blend of danger and sophistication, kept Bunny entangled in a web of crime and friendship. As they navigated the treacherous paths of Victorian society, their partnership endured, a testament to the complex interplay of loyalty, deception, and the unbreakable bond between a gentleman thief and his devoted companion.

Main Characters

  • A. J. Raffles: The protagonist, a charming and cunning gentleman thief. His dual life as a celebrated cricketer and a master burglar showcases his ability to navigate different worlds with ease. Raffles is portrayed as both a hero and a villain, embodying the complexities of his character.
  • Bunny Manders: The narrator and Raffles’ devoted companion. Bunny’s internal conflicts and unwavering loyalty to Raffles provide a deeper emotional layer to the stories. His journey reflects his struggle between his admiration for Raffles and his own moral compass.
  • Unnamed Fiancée: Bunny’s former love interest, whose brief appearance highlights the personal cost of his association with Raffles. Her presence serves as a reminder of Bunny’s lost potential for a respectable life.

Themes and Motifs

  • Loyalty and Betrayal: The bond between Raffles and Bunny is central to the stories, showcasing the complexities of loyalty. Bunny’s unwavering support for Raffles, despite his misgivings, highlights the theme of loyalty, while Raffles’ manipulations often border on betrayal.
  • Moral Ambiguity: The stories explore the gray areas of morality, challenging the reader to reconsider traditional notions of right and wrong. Raffles’ actions, though criminal, are often depicted with a sense of gallantry and justification.
  • Social Class and Identity: The dual lives of Raffles as a gentleman and a thief highlight the fluidity of social identity. The stories critique the rigid class structures of Victorian society and explore the idea of identity as a construct.

Writing Style and Tone

Ernest William Hornung’s writing style in “A Thief in the Night” is characterized by its elegance, wit, and attention to detail. Hornung employs a first-person narrative through Bunny, providing a personal and intimate glimpse into the world of Raffles. The tone is often reflective and tinged with a sense of nostalgia, particularly in Bunny’s recounting of their adventures. Hornung’s prose is rich with vivid descriptions and clever dialogues, capturing the essence of late Victorian London and the thrill of the heist.

The narrative technique is particularly effective in creating suspense and building character depth. Hornung’s use of irony and humor adds a layer of sophistication to the stories, making them engaging and thought-provoking. The portrayal of Raffles as a complex anti-hero and the moral dilemmas faced by Bunny contribute to the enduring appeal of these tales.

Opinions are my own and not the views of my employer (if any)

When I am not working/watching movies/reading books/traveling, you can reach me via my Twitter/LinkedIn or you can contact me here

Categories: Book Summary